One Pie Pizza Co

4.7 ( 376 reviews )
Checking... 9:00 AM - 8:00 PM See Hours
2185 Clinton St, West Seneca, NY 14206, United States
+1 716-822-1222
One Pie Pizza Co, located at 2185 Clinton St in West Seneca, NY, is quickly becoming a standout in the competitive pizza scene. Their menu boasts a delectable range of pizzas, including unique combinations like the Buffalo Chicken Finger Pizza and the alluring Pepperoni Hot Honey Ricotta. Customers rave about the crust, which has been described as a perfect blend of crunchy edges and a chewy center, reminiscent of Detroit-style pizza. The sweet yet well-seasoned red sauce pairs beautifully with high-quality toppings like cup and char pepperoni, further elevating the taste experience. Greg VanMeter notes the originality of their offerings, while Jamie Nicoloff highlights the generous portions and complimentary homemade blue cheese, a delightful addition that has customers coming back for more. Whether you're enjoying a classic large slice or venturing into their Frozen Take and Bake options like the Banana Pepper Crunch Roll, the satisfaction is clear. One Pie Pizza Co proves that quality ingredients and innovative recipes can create an unforgettable dining experience, even without a dine-in option. With each pizza, you can taste the passion and care that goes into crafting these pies. It's no wonder why diners are obsessed—this pizzeria is truly a gem!

Amenities and More

  • Accessibility
    • Has wheelchair-accessible car park
    • Has wheelchair-accessible entrance
  • Service options
    • Has no-contact delivery
    • Offers delivery
    • On-site services available
    • Offers takeaway
    • Serves dine-in
  • Popular for
    • Popular for lunch
    • Popular for dinner
  • Offerings
    • Serves comfort food
    • Quick bite
  • Dining options
    • Serves lunch
    • Serves dinner
    • Serves dessert
    • Has seating
  • Amenities
    • No toilet
  • Atmosphere
    • Casual
  • Planning
    • Accepts reservations
  • Payments
    • Accepts credit cards
    • Accepts debit cards
    • Accepts NFC mobile payments
    • Credit cards
  • Children
    • Good for kids
    • High chairs available
  • Parking
    • Free of charge street parking
    • Free parking lot
    • Plenty of parking

Reviews For One Pie Pizza Co

Greg VanMeter
May 30,2025
Some of the best and most original pizza I have had in a long time. Sweet sauce is not too sweet and has great taste. Crust, cheese and pep were fantastic too. Really good job guys. Will definitely be ordering again!
cranium2001
May 24,2025
Wow. What more can I say than that? This is by far one of the best pizzas I've ever had. The crust was incredible, the sauce was unbelievable, and the pepperoni was perfect. No dine in option, but that's okay because it's that good. One tip I would add is that I'll get extra sauce next time. It was a decent amount, but by the time I got home over an hour away the crust had soaked up some of the sauce. I obviously had a slice there when I picked it up, so I could tell a difference.
Shannon Rose
May 17,2025
First time trying One Pie Pizza. We ordered the ricotta, pepperoni & hot honey pizza and the chicken and waffles pizza. 1/2 sheet each. The crust is crunchy on the sides somewhat like a Detroit style with a chewy middle. The ingredients are fresh and compliment each other well. The garlic butter crust on the breakfast pizza stood out and definitely enhanced the flavor overall. The homemade blue cheese is excellent and I highly recommend picking up a few. The red sauce on the pepperoni pizza is sweet but also has a good amount of seasoning in it. The pepperoni is cup and char style. The hot honey wasn't very hot so I added red pepper flakes. The flavor itself was delicious though and I'd order it again.
Jamie Nicoloff
May 4,2025
My favorite! I'm obsessed with the Buffalo Chicken Finger Pizza, and hubby loves the Pepperoni Hot Honey Ricotta. This place never disappoints. The quality of the ingredients is definitely noticeable, and they don't skimp on toppings. The crust/dough is perfection, and the blue cheese is delicious! I love that they give you a complimentary cup of their homemade blue cheese with each pizza. Keep up the great work, One Pie!
Kyle Matesic
Apr 10,2025
First timer. Friend recommended. Very good. Cooked very well. Sauce was semi sweet and delicious great cup n char. Great cheese. Looks like it could have been overcooked but the dough and crust was perfect for my taste. Little bit on the softer side. Ordered online. Picked up at the desired time
Blayne Robson
Mar 23,2025
Wish I could make sheet pizza this good. I can't. I can't touch how great the dough is. Looking at it I was expecting something heavy from a crust so thick, but it was nice and light. There was weight to the slice though. The toppings. Plenty of'em. And great quality. I might try well done next time, because I'm a big fan of Detroit pies, but honestly why try to make something so good into something that it isn't. Good job One Pie Pizza Co. Keep doing you.
J K
Feb 13,2025
I was very reluctant to try this pizza because it says it has sweet sauce and I hate sweet sauce. The first order I got a cheese and pepperoni pizza with half mushroom and half cherry peppers. First let me say that this is a high quality pizza, it's very flavorful and everything is made from scratch. The cherry peppers were delicious!!!, and the flavor and heat from them drastically cut the sweetness of the sauce... As does the flavor and spice of the pepperoni. I guess it depends on the toppings you get if you really pick up on the sweetness of it. I enjoyed the pizza and would suggest for others to give it a try even if they don't like sweet sauce because it is quite flavorful and the sauce still has enough of a savory profile that you're not overwhelmed with sweetness. The homemade blue cheese that comes with the pizza was also really good. I also love that they use fresh mushrooms and not canned. Update* ordered many times since, those cherry peppers are addicting!
Conor Vile
Feb 5,2025
Just tried the upside down pizza last night. May be my new favorite slice in Buffalo. They’ve managed to make the perfect combination of sauce, cheese, and flavor. I will definitely be ordering this a lot in the future!

Add a Review

Quality
Location
Price
Space
Service

Location

Appreciated by Others

Donair Dude
(230 review)
Donair Dude
  • 258 Newport Dr, Port Moody, BC V3H 5C6, Canada
Mediterranean restaurant
+1 604-492-0340
Steiny's Pub
(434 review)
Steiny's Pub
  • 3 Hyatt St, Staten Island, NY 10301, United States
Bar & grill
+1 718-442-9526
Snooze, an A.M. Eatery
(372 review)
Snooze, an A.M. Eatery
  • 101 N Broadway #1, Denver, CO 80203, United States
Breakfast restaurant
+1 720-443-4540
Zaxbys Chicken Fingers & Buffalo Wings
(414 review)
Zaxbys Chicken Fingers & Buffalo Wings
  • 2574 Jackson Ave W, Oxford, MS 38655, United States
Chicken restaurant
+1 662-234-1024
The Grille on Congress
(696 review)
The Grille on Congress
  • 5101 Congress Ave, Boca Raton, FL 33487, United States
Restaurant
+1 561-912-9800
Fiesta Charra
(568 review)
Fiesta Charra
  • 25 W High St, Oxford, OH 45056, United States
Mexican restaurant
+1 513-524-3114
Crafty Coyote
(1130 review)
Crafty Coyote
  • 511 Bloor St W, Toronto, ON M5S 1Y4, Canada
Bar
+1 647-748-2338
Mizu Sushi
(1186 review)
Mizu Sushi
  • 1320 SW Ashworth Pl, Topeka, KS 66604, United States
Sushi restaurant
+1 785-783-3880
Narrow Bridge Plate Pour
(583 review)
Narrow Bridge Plate Pour
  • 2840 Shawano Ave, Green Bay, WI 54313, United States
Restaurant
+1 920-393-4015
Chick-fil-A
(2719 review)
Chick-fil-A
  • 1530 Old Country Rd, Westbury, NY 11590, United States
Fast food restaurant
+1 516-222-2530